Sort by *
PRESS RELEASE
24 May 2022
Public report
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT FUNDING IN OVERSEAS
TERRITORIES
The repeated social tensions - linked in particular to employment, inequality and insecurity
- that the overseas territories experienced between 2006 and 2009, then again in 2017 in
French Guiana and 2018 in Mayotte and Reunion, underline the continued, even worsening,
economic and social vulnerabilities of these territories.Central government tried to respond
to each of these crises by implementing a number of emergency plans, and by significantly
increasing its budgetary effort.In 2021, the overall budget (budget expenditures and tax
expenditures) earmarked to support overseas territories public policies amounted to €27.3
billion, excluding social expenditures, representing 11% more than in 2020.Despite this
increased commitment from central government to the overseas territories, the Court
observes
an
underperformance
of
the
expenditure
approved.
In
addition,
the
Interdepartmental Overseas Policy Paper (DPT)
–describing the state’s interdepartmental
action overseas
proves to be comprehensive, but ultimately not useful for informing
Parliament about central government’s strategy and the extent to which actions have
succeeded. In the report published today, the Court makes ten recommendations that
would, among other things, improve the information given to parliamentarians and the
public.
Increased central government investment, but mixed results
In particular, France’s law on real equality overseas of 28 February 2017 set a target for the
convergence of the overseas territories and continental France and, for the last five years,
central government has financed a significant portion of public investments overseas. In 2021,
this effort was reflected in a significant amount of budget spending passed by Parliament (€20.9
billion), but also in particularly high tax expenditure (€6.3 billion)
- making overall spending up
11% compared to 2020. Tax expenditure, the effectiveness and efficiency of which in
benefitting overseas territories have never been clearly demonstrated, represents a significant
loss of earnings for the central government budget, even though they are never seriously
assessed. Despite the significant investments made by central government, obvious inequalities
persist, exacerbated in French Guiana and Mayotte by sharp population growth, explaining the
very significant under-consumption of funding. While it is necessary to make the appropriation
of funds dedicated to overseas territories more efficient with regard to the capacities of the
territories to spend them, the Court also stresses the importance of better support for local
authorities, in acquiring the engineering skills necessary to manage investment operations.
An Interdepartmental Overseas Policy Paper (DPT) that can definitely be improved
Created in 2006, the Interdepartmental Overseas Policy Paper (DPT), which aims to present all
of the budget funding and tax expenditure allocated to overseas territories each year, requires
interdepartmental coordination that is particularly burdensome to implement. This document
is, however, very little used in budgetary debates, and is even less accessible to the general
public. Voluminous and presenting in great detail the resources devolved to public intervention
in the overseas territories, the DPT suffers, in its current format, from a lack of clarity.
Furthermore, it is not available within the timeframes allowing Parliament to make use of it
before budget debates under the budget bill. Several development scenarios are proposed,
which would not only
improve its relevance, but also enhance Parliament’s and the public’s
information, giving more meaning to the Paper. The Court therefore considers that such an
improvement in the budget framework for presenting and executing its expenditure, while
probably not sufficient to guarantee the effectiveness of central government action, would
make it possible to better meet the challenge of convergence between metropolitan France
and the overseas territories.
Read the report
PRESS CONTACTS:
Emmanuel Kessler
Director of Communications
T
+33 (0)1 42 98 97 43
+33 (0)6 62 48 07 81
emmanuel.kessler@ccomptes.fr
Julie Poissier
Head of Press Relations
T
+33 (0)1 42 98 97 43
+33 (0)6 87 36 52 21
julie.poissier@ccomptes.fr
@Courdescomptes
ccomptes
Cour des comptes
Cour des comptes